South meets North – A partnership linking sooty falcon conservationists
The sooty falcon (Falco concolor) is a medium-sized falcon that breeds solely in the Middle East and north-eastern Africa, and winters in Madagascar and the SE African mainland. Oman, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt are important breeding areas. Unlike most falcons, the sooty falcon breeds late in the summer, feeding its young on birds that are migrating from Eurasia to Africa. Thus, it is both migratory itself, and highly dependent on the health of migratory populations of small birds to ensure its long-term persistence. As such its conservation is supported in a general way by the CMS approach aimed at conserving migrant species, and more specifically though the focused CMS effort spelled out in the MOU on Birds of Prey. Sooty falcons breed singly or in aggregations. Aggregations are found on islands and can be large, making those islands particularly important for conservation. One of the largest aggregations in the world occurs on Fahal Island, located about 5 km from the Omani capital, Muscat. The conservation status of the sooty falcon has been recently downgraded by BirdLife International to “Near-threatened” (http://www.birdlife.org/datazone/speciesfactsheet.php?id=3606 last accessed 8 May 2012). It is classified as a Category 1 species under the CMS Action Plan for the conservation of Migratory Birds of Prey in Africa and Eurasia. Research to date, including recent work in Oman supported by the OCE, point to an estimated 15% decline in the population in recent decades, and that human disturbance, illegal killing and habitat loss are threats. It is arguably a good flagship species for conservation, but has never been used as such. Therefore, more general conservation efforts are not benefitting from its flagship species status. In recent years the OCE in Oman has supported the most extensive study in the world and survey of sooty falcons on its breeding grounds. A recent report can be downloaded here: http://www.natural-research.org/environmental-research-charity/current-… . Although the OCE has lead on this effort, it has relied on the cooperation of Omani government, academic business and non-governmental organizations and international wildlife research organizations. A basic assumption of the Convention is that migratory species' conservation requires whole-range and trans-national approaches. The countries within the annual range of the sooty falcon are developing (Madagascar is classified by the UN as a "least developed" country (See Annex A) , often have large remote areas where sooty falcons are found, and in general dedicate few resources to wildlife conservation. Accepting the importance of building a range-wide partnership, it is reasonable to start by building a partnership between the country in which most sooty falcons winter (Madagascar) and a country that has a significant proportion of the breeding population and a history of sooty falcon research (Oman). Once this seed- partnership between these two countries is established, a larger group of cooperating countries can be assembled.
There is a lack of information on sooty falcons, particularly on the wintering grounds. There is a lack of trans-national collaboration within the range of the sooty falcon, particularly between the breeding range states and the non-breeding range states. These deficiencies undermine sooty falcon conservation. In addition, the sooty falcon is a potential flagship species, but because of a lack of public outreach and education this status, which would be beneficial to achieving wider conservation objectives, is not being harnessed. The whole of Madagascar is a biodiversity hotspot. Similarly, Oman is biologically rich because of its diverse landscape that straddles the border between Africa and Eurasia. The main breeding areas of sooty falcons are designated as Important Bird Areas, and the Daymaniyat Islands (which hold about 40% of the known nests in Oman) comprise the only marine nature reserve in Oman. As a Category 1 species in the CMS Action Plan for the Conservation of Migratory Birds of Prey, the sooty falcon's conservation is a priority. This proposal supports the Action Plan's objective of halting and reversing the population decline of this Near Threatened raptor. This proposal also adopts and supports prioritiy actions cited by the Action Plan, including (but not limited to): protection from unlawful killing; conservation of sooty falcon habitats; protection and appropriate management of important sites; raising of awareness about sooty falcons (and other species); assessing and monitoring of sooty falcons throughout the Range States to establish reliable population trends; undertaking research to identify threats to sooty falcons and the measures that are needed to counter them; sharing of information between Range States; undertaking research into sooty falcon ecology and migratory behaviour; and building capacity for conservation actions (in relevant institutions and local communities in both Oman and Madagascar). The proposed work builds on the CMS funded Action Plan, and addresses sooty falcon-specific needs cited in that plan, including: identifying areas important to sooty falcons on migration and on the wintering grounds, improving sooty falcon protection, raising public awareness to promote sooty falcon conservation and conducting conservation focussed sooty falcon population monitoring and research. There are two phases to this proposal to link Madagascar and Oman, and promote a geographically and temporally-whole approach to sooty falcon conservation: 1) a visit during the breeding season to Oman by Malagasy biologist/conservationists, and then 2) a visit by Omani biologists to Madagascar during the sooty falcon non-breeding season. Visits at both times will have strategic planning and field research components, the aim of which will be to educate and build a team from Madagascar and Oman so that a holistic approach to sooty falcon conservation can be taken. These visits will be linked to one another in a way by the tracking movements of sooty falcons between the two countries using satellites. The purpose of the visit by a Malagasy team to Oman is to initiate the building of a partnership between the two countries by allowing Malagasys to participate in breeding ground surveys, fit sooty falcons with satellite transmitters and learn how to track them. Formal and informal discussions will aim to develop a strategy for continued cooperative work between the two countries, and consider how best to develop a multi-state, range-wide cooperative network based on an Oman-Madagascar kernel. It is worth noting that preliminary analyses undertaken in Oman in cooperation with researchers at Sultan Qaboos University have shown agricultural chemicals to be present in sooty falcons. Because Oman is not an agricultural country these chemicals must come from other areas, including Madagascar. The visit to Oman will enable Malagasys to discuss ways forward in contaminant sample collection and analyses to better understand their potential impact on the falcons. Funding will be used to purchase a single satellite transmitter and its satellite time for a year as a Malagasy "buy-in" to the larger tracking project being undertaken by the Omanis. This tag will be an identifiable fulcrum on which the results from other falcons being tracked by the OCE can be leveraged for public outreach and education, especially in Madagascar. Because this tag will be tracked at the same time as others, it will both benefit the effort to understand falcon movements by adding to the sample size, and receive benefit from the project by being tracked with other individuals. Funding is also sought to support travel by biologists working in Oman to Madagascar in early 2013. This trip will enable workshops/meetings to be held, and pilot field work to be undertaken in Madagascar. The aims of the field work will be to gather basic data on sooty falcon numbers and winter ecology, to gather information useful in planning future collaborative (particularly winter-time) work important for conservation, and to solidify the working partnership between Oman and Madagascar. The purpose of the workshops/ meetings will be to review the existing Action Plan, prioritize tasks and determine how those tasks might be tackled. The visit to Madagascar will allow the team to create a target list of likely funders and partners and to draft a global proposal that can be the foundation for approaches to funders. Recognizing that some funders/partners may be interested in only some of the priority tasks identified by the team, the global proposal should lend itself to being "dissembled" for the purpose of matching potential funders and partners with the priority tasks. This phase of the proposed work is of utmost importance. Having built a team that will have experience in both the wintering and summering grounds, it is important that the team is positioned to move beyond the CMS small grant stage and sustain a long-term effort aimed at conservation of sooty falcon across its range. Although the most important output of the proposed work will be the building of a team, the second most important will be a strategic plan and proposals that will enable future work and ensure that the CMS small grant investment pays off.
Implicitly CMS recognizes that a whole-range approach is needed to best achieve conservation objectives, most especially for migratory species like the sooty falcon. For most migratory species of birds more is known about their ecology on the breeding grounds, and many gaps exist in our understanding of the year-round ecology of sooty falcons. Also, little information is available on processes (e.g. natal dispersal) and important population and demographic parameters (e.g. survival, productivity and recruitment). Additionally, there is little public knowledge of the sooty falcon in the countries in which it occurs, illustrating that conservation education is lacking. While there is a general lack of information and conservation effort, these deficiencies are most pronounced in the non-breeding areas of Madagascar (and the African mainland). Despite the perception that that breeding grounds are most important, sooty falcons spend more time away from the breeding grounds than on them, and in any case breeding falcons also need to survive the non-breeding season in order to return to breed summmer after summer.
Establish connections between sooty falcon conservationists and researchers working in the breeding grounds in Oman and their counterparts working on the non-breeding grounds in Madagascar.; Use the experience and momentum in sooty falcon research in Oman to leverage a complimentary effort on the non-breeding grounds in Madagascar.; Collect data useful for sooty falcon conservaton in the field; Use data to initiate public outreach and education. Dissemination of information
S:\UNIT - Science\Small Grants Programme\SGP 2012\Winners 2012\MG2
OCE to arrange all logistics to get guests into the field and faciltate meeting in Oman. OCE to purchase satellite transmitters. Mdm Zarasoa /Rene de Roland Lily Arison to arrange all logistics in Madagascar.
Report on field work in Oman
Working strategy document that sets out taks and timeframe for future cooperation and a plan fpr growing the group of cooperators
Report on field work in Madagascar
Field visit by Malagasys to Oman in October 2012. Participate in field work including fitting of satellite tags and survey of falcons. Strategy meeting at OCE in Oman Visit by OCE biologists to Madagascar in early 2013. Planning meetings and pilot field
OCE (Mansoor al Jadhami, Waheed al Fazari, Dawood al Adjimi) and M. McGrady to arrange survey. M. McGrady to provide training on downloading and displaying tracking data.
Report on field work in Oman.
Contributes to peer reviewed scientific paper being planned that will use data from previous 4 yrs of field effort.
Blog with postings of maps of tracked birds.
Survey sooty falcons on Fahal Island Track sooty falcons fitted with satellite transmitters in Oman.
OCE biologists and M. McGrady to lead on field work in Oman
OCE biologists to download and archive information on tracked birds.
Malagasy biologists to lead on field work in Madagascar
Field reports
Plan peer reviewed papers. Field work in Madagascar likely to be tooo little for anything but a short note, perhaps in Bird Conservatioin International or Sandgrouse. Oman data can be added to past data for publication of a long article
Survey and monitor sooty falcon population in Oman; Extend mark-recapture field work in Oman Track sooty falcons fitted with satellite transmitters in Oman. Pilot field work in Madagascar
OCE biologists and M McGrady to maintain blog in Arabic and English, and make data available to Malagasys. Consider setting up Facebook page
Lily Arison to maintain blog in French and Malagasy
Establishment of web presence, preferably in French, English, and Arabic
Track sooty falcons fitted with satellite transmitters in Oman. Determine format for blogs/websites Create web presence in French, English and Arabic Produce popular and peer-reviewed scientific publications
75% upon signature<br />
25% upon receipt of final report